Matthew Hayes, brother of convicted Petit murderer Steven, believes in the possibility of redemption - and that all mankind should have a shot at it. His words about that, introduced at the penalty phase of the Hayes's trial, could save save his brother.
So far the defense has seemed to hit a wall in its tactics. The judge threw out its motion to toss the death penalty because of its cost to taxpayers. The testimony about Hayes as a likable guy, funny and a good worker was undermined by other testimony which documented that he threatened to kill an official in prison because he had nothing to lose. So much for his being a clueless follower of his partner in crime.
However, an appeal to the value of redemption has legs. Most of us believe that evil can be exorcised by repentance and a turning toward good. Supposedly the notorious Son of Sam found his better self in prison. And it was in prison that then street trash Malcolm found a calling higher than his primitive instincts toward hate.
No one I talk to in Connecticut feels anything positive about Hayes. However, this is a Christian state and most feel they should hate the sin but love the sinner, including allowing the possibility for salvation.
If the defense is as smart as it seems it will have Matthew's words resonate in closing arguments.
Comments