It's just out - JOURNAL OF THE PLAGUE YEAR: An Insider's Chronicle of Eliot Spitzer's Short and Tragic Reign.
The insider author is Lloyd Constantine, former senior adviser to Eliot Spitzer when he was New York governor. This book is useful for those of us who have become fascinated with political public relations, including the palace intrigue which President Barack Obama alludes to. The narrative, of course, is a chronicle of the lackluster job Spitzer did as governor and his eventual fall from grace. But, that might not be why it will be read closely and discussed, especially by us communications pros. Unlike Andrew Young's THE POLITICIAN, it isn't filled with titillating details.
Constantine, who had supervised Spitzer when he was an intern from Harvard Law at the NY Attorney General's office, deconstructs bad and good PR moves by brandname political players, including himself. Yes, in a sense he's a version of the Fallible First Person Narrator. The only difference is that he is already aware of his flaws. Because the tale is from an insider's point of view the discussions and insights can help communications firms with their political clients.
For a speechwriter like myself I was thrilled that Constantine spotted as a red flag that the newly installed governor Spitzer did not have a professional speechwriter. The author's theory - and it's his theory - was that Spitzer's secret life, which has commenced before he became governor, was tearing him apart. Instead of the totally focused Spitzer of High Integrity there was an often distracted one who made such serious errors of judgment. That Spitzer 2.0 Constantine calls The Imposter. It was not the man he had supervised years before and had as a close friend for a quarter of a century.
Sans professional speechwriter, Spitzer allowed the crafting of his State of the Union in 2007 to be done by a committee of his aides. Of course, it was poorly constructed, as is all work of ambitious committee members who value their input more than the value of it. What saved it from disaster was the Spitzer aura which still was palpable and his strong delivery.
Other mistakes weren't so understandable. Why, for instance, did Spitzer publicly humiliate those who he didn't have to during his Inaugural Speech. The victims ranged from the outgoing George Pataki to the weakened Joe Bruno. Constantine repeats something he had said to his wife at the time:
"He's [Bruno] on his way out - all Eliot has to do is show him some respect, and he will behave."
No surprise, Spitzer made plenty of needless enemies that day and New York paid for it when its House and Senate wouldn't play ball with Spitzer.
Another enlightening insider bit is that contacting a reporter while he or she is writing the story can change the slant. Constantine was tipped off that a NEW YORK TIMES journalist Danny Hakim had misinterpreted Spitzer's support of Hillary Clinton versus his, that is Constantine's, early support of Obama. When he explained the facts, Hakim "changed the story." So, yes, make that call.
The most sensational disclosure is that Constantine recommended that Spitzer take the rehab cooling-off period. He could do his 28 days for sex addiction. When he returned he would make the ritualistic mea culpa, take the last of the heat from the media, and work very very hard. For some reason, Spitzer didn't follow that shrewd advice. It might have saved New York. Part of the reason for the mess it's in, we now know, is the seemingly below-average leadership of David Paterson. I am convinced that Spitzer could have hung in. Did he cave because he was so full of shame about The Imposter he had become?
JOURNAL OF THE PLAGUE YEAR could be used as a textbook in a Public Relations advanced seminar. There would be heated debate about if Spitzer should have and could have continued on as governor.
One more thing: Constantine is not a communications expert. He is a lawyer with a special area of expertise in antitrust. Currently, he is counsel to Constantine Cannon LLP, with offices in New York and Washington D.C. Right now he's on business in India. When he returns, he promises readers of this blog an exclusive interview.